Calling Bullshit on the Daily Mail’s Terrible Coverage of Bute’s Syrian Refugees

DSCF1264

George Square in Glasgow, September 2015

When the UK’s first planeload of Syrian refugees landed at Glasgow Airport last December, it sparked a small media frenzy. Since then, however, most of the 400 refugees who have sought shelter in Scotland – having come via camps in Lebanon – have been left alone and allowed to get on with rebuilding their lives, dispersed across 16 different council areas.

All, that is, except the 15 families who were placed on the Isle of Bute, the island of 6,000 nestled in the Firth of Clyde. Partly the mythologised view of life on “remote” Scottish islands and partly the ease of tracking the refugees down (in an otherwise near ethnically homogenous community) has led to a situation where they can’t even visit the local Londis without being jumped on by day-tripping New Statesman writers. But while most coverage has been sympathic, some have had other ideas.

Step forward the Daily Mail. In December, just days after the refugee families had arrived,  the newspaper despatched a reporter to the island to tell the story of a “small society that risks being fractured”. Try as they did, the paper struggled to come up with anything earth shattering – a few anecdotes from disgruntled locals and pointedly passive questions aside: How will they possible adjust to the weather? Why are they getting such special treatment? How will they possibly learn the value of money?  The refugees themselves, reportedly on advice from the local council, refused to speak to the Mail reporter or the Arabic translator they took along with them. “Inevitably, this wall of silence fosters resentment,” the reporter presumptiously surmises.

But the Mail wanted an interview with Bute’s refugees and, eventually it seems, their persistence paid off. On Monday of this week, the paper splashed with a follow-up article alleging that two of the refugee families on the island are unhappy living there. The implication, of course, being that they are ungrateful, that they should go back to Syria if they hate it so much, that Bute is the kind of picturesque idyll that Home Counties Mail readers dream of retiring to, so how can they possibly not be happy… and so on.

mail-bute

Regardless of whether the quotes included in the article were manipulated or mistranslated, as some have alleged, if the recent settlers on the island aren’t having the time of their lives on Bute it should not be news. They are from a country that is being torn apart by a brutal war and where many of their friends and relatives still live. Moving to a new town or city is disorientating at the best of times – but in the context of fleeing conflict, it must be unimaginable. Take in the culture shock, religious and language differences and lack of any existing Arabic-speaking community and it’s not suprising if some are feeling isolated, or even depressed. Nor is Bute some kind of paradise. The island faces the same social and economic problems seen across Scotland – alienation, low pay, bad jobs, service cuts – with the added factor of geographic isolation.

The only people who have acted shamefully here are the editorial staff at the Mail, who have cynically fed these quotes to their audience in full awareness of how they will be interpreted. While the article doesn’t pursue the same line of passive questioning as last December’s hitpiece, that’s only because it doesn’t need to. The dog whistle is loud enough.

The far-right in Scotland – pathetic as they are – are already trying to capitalise on the situation. Various UKIP figures have spent this week gleefully tweeting the Mail article. Earlier this year, the remnants of the Scottish BNP boasted of sending targeted mailshots to Bute residents, purportedly in a bid to canvass their views.

Fortunately, islanders are fighting back against the hatred being peddled by those with an outside agenda. A Facebook post by someone from Bute has gone viral this week, slamming the Mail for their “shocking abuse” of trust in the situation. Tellingly, a couple of members of Rothesay’s new Syrian community have commented on the post. “I am so happy to live here on the island, it’s very beautiful place to live in, with the nice and friendly people we are already in our new home. Thank you for your good hospitality,” one writes.

The stirring up of resentment and division in a small community is not plunging any new depths for the Daily Mail. However, it’s up to all of us to challenge their bile.

——————————————————————————————

Further Reading:

Beyond an Image: Practical Ways to Support Refugees

Photos: Thousands Rally in Glasgow to say: Refugees Welcome

Will bombs bring peace to the Middle East?

——————————————————————————————

Find us on Facebook at www.facebook.com/AThousandFlowers

Follow us on Twitter @unsavourycabal

—————————————————————————————————

Advertisements

5 responses to “Calling Bullshit on the Daily Mail’s Terrible Coverage of Bute’s Syrian Refugees

  1. As a former resident of Rothesay when I was at Rothesay Academy we always used to joke that the Island was a cross between a retirement home and an internment camp and of my age group almost all of us left the Island as soon as we left School and have not looked back (which wasn’t that long ago). I have concerns over employment options on the island as hit has gone through over 30 years of almost no development and what jobs they do have are very often seasonal or low skill. It would have been better to house people in an area with more resources especially educational and employment so that the refugees have a higher chance of building a new life as these people need help

  2. I spent about an hour last night reporting racist comments on their Facebook post for review, none of them were upheld. I then spent a while searching around for some formal way of challenging the Daily Mail in the form of pressure groups etc. but found nothing. What is the best way to tackle this problem?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s